Most Fuel Efficient Used Cars to Save on Gas
With gas prices fluctuating and environmental consciousness growing, finding a fuel-efficient used car has become a top priority for Regina drivers. Whether you're commuting to downtown Regina, making trips to Saskatoon, or navigating Saskatchewan's vast highways, choosing the right fuel-efficient vehicle can save you hundreds of dollars annually while reducing your environmental footprint.
This comprehensive guide examines the most fuel-efficient used cars available in the Canadian market, focusing on models that perform well in Saskatchewan's climate while delivering exceptional fuel economy. We'll compare real-world fuel consumption, reliability records, and value propositions to help you make an informed decision.
How We Selected These Fuel-Efficient Champions
Our comparison focuses on several key criteria that matter most to Saskatchewan drivers:
- Real-world fuel economy: Official ratings versus actual consumption in Canadian driving conditions
- Cold weather performance: How efficiency holds up during Regina's harsh winters
- Reliability and maintenance costs: Long-term ownership expenses beyond fuel savings
- Availability and pricing: What you can realistically find in the used car market
- Practicality: Balancing efficiency with everyday usability
We've excluded plug-in hybrids and electric vehicles to focus on traditional gasoline engines and conventional hybrids that don't require charging infrastructure.
The Top 5 Most Fuel Efficient Used Cars
1. Toyota Prius (2016-2020)
Fuel Economy: 4.5L/100km combined Typical Used Price Range: $18,000 - $28,000 CAD
The Toyota Prius remains the gold standard for fuel efficiency in the used car market. This fourth-generation Prius delivers exceptional fuel economy while maintaining Toyota's reputation for reliability.
Pros:
- Outstanding fuel economy in all driving conditions
- Proven hybrid technology with minimal maintenance requirements
- Excellent resale value retention
- Spacious interior despite compact exterior dimensions
- Advanced safety features standard on most trim levels
Cons:
- Polarizing exterior styling
- Road noise at highway speeds
- Less engaging driving experience
- Premium for hybrid technology versus conventional cars
Saskatchewan Considerations: The Prius performs admirably in cold weather, though fuel economy drops to approximately 5.5L/100km during harsh winter conditions. The hybrid battery system includes thermal management that helps maintain performance in temperatures down to -30°C.
2. Honda Civic (2016-2021)
Fuel Economy: 6.7L/100km combined (CVT transmission) Typical Used Price Range: $16,000 - $25,000 CAD
The tenth-generation Honda Civic represents an excellent balance of fuel efficiency, reliability, and driving enjoyment. The turbocharged 1.5L engine delivers impressive fuel economy without sacrificing performance.
Pros:
- Excellent fuel economy for a non-hybrid vehicle
- Engaging driving dynamics
- Spacious interior and large trunk
- Strong reliability record
- Lower purchase price than hybrid alternatives
Cons:
- CVT transmission feels less responsive than traditional automatic
- Turbo engine requires premium fuel for optimal performance
- Some early models experienced oil dilution issues in cold climates
Saskatchewan Considerations: The Civic's turbocharged engine performs well in cold weather once warmed up. However, short trips in winter conditions can impact fuel economy more significantly than naturally aspirated engines. A block heater is recommended for Regina winters.
3. Toyota Corolla Hybrid (2020-2022)
Fuel Economy: 4.8L/100km combined Typical Used Price Range: $22,000 - $30,000 CAD
Toyota's newest hybrid offering brings Prius-like efficiency to a more conventional sedan package. The Corolla Hybrid uses a simplified version of Toyota's proven hybrid system.
Pros:
- Near-Prius fuel economy in a traditional sedan body
- More conventional styling than Prius
- Toyota's hybrid reliability
- Comprehensive warranty coverage on hybrid components
- Smooth, quiet operation
Cons:
- Limited availability in the used market
- Higher purchase price than conventional Corolla
- Smaller trunk due to hybrid battery placement
- Less rear seat space than previous Corolla generations
Saskatchewan Considerations: Being a newer model, cold weather data is limited, but Toyota's hybrid systems have consistently performed well in Canadian winters. The conventional sedan shape also provides better aerodynamics in crosswinds common on Saskatchewan highways.
4. Nissan Versa (2017-2019)
Fuel Economy: 7.1L/100km combined Typical Used Price Range: $12,000 - $18,000 CAD
The Nissan Versa offers exceptional fuel economy at a budget-friendly price point. While not as refined as Honda or Toyota competitors, it delivers genuine value for cost-conscious buyers.
Pros:
- Excellent fuel economy for the price point
- Spacious interior relative to exterior size
- Lower purchase and insurance costs
- Simple, reliable naturally aspirated engine
- Good warranty coverage when purchased used
Cons:
- CVT transmission reliability concerns
- Interior materials feel cheap
- Limited resale value
- Less engaging driving experience
- Road noise and vibration at highway speeds
Saskatchewan Considerations: The Versa's naturally aspirated engine performs consistently in cold weather, though the CVT transmission may feel sluggish during warm-up periods. The lower purchase price makes it attractive for budget-conscious Regina buyers.
5. Hyundai Elantra (2017-2020)
Fuel Economy: 7.4L/100km combined Typical Used Price Range: $14,000 - $22,000 CAD
The sixth-generation Elantra combines good fuel economy with Hyundai's comprehensive warranty coverage and competitive pricing in the used market.
Pros:
- Solid fuel economy with conventional powertrain
- Comprehensive warranty transferable to second owners
- Competitive pricing in used market
- Well-equipped even in base trim levels
- Comfortable ride quality
Cons:
- Not class-leading in any particular area
- Some interior materials feel cheap
- Engine can be noisy under acceleration
- Depreciation affects resale value
Saskatchewan Considerations: The Elantra's conventional powertrain performs predictably in cold weather. Hyundai's warranty coverage provides peace of mind for used car buyers, though transferability terms should be verified with dealers.
Fuel Economy Comparison Table
| Vehicle | Combined L/100km | Winter L/100km* | Used Price Range |
|---|---|---|---|
| Toyota Prius | 4.5 | 5.5 | $18,000-$28,000 |
| Toyota Corolla Hybrid | 4.8 | 5.8** | $22,000-$30,000 |
| Honda Civic | 6.7 | 8.2 | $16,000-$25,000 |
| Nissan Versa | 7.1 | 8.8 | $12,000-$18,000 |
| Hyundai Elantra | 7.4 | 9.1 | $14,000-$22,000 |
*Estimated winter fuel consumption in Saskatchewan conditions **Limited real-world data due to newer model
What to Consider When Shopping
When browsing fuel-efficient used cars in Regina, several factors beyond fuel economy deserve attention:
Maintenance History: Hybrid vehicles require specialized service, so verify that previous owners maintained the vehicle at qualified facilities. For conventional engines, regular oil changes become even more critical with smaller, more efficient powertrains.
Cold Weather Packages: Look for vehicles equipped with block heaters, remote starters, and heated seats. These features improve comfort and can actually improve fuel economy by reducing warm-up time.
Tire Condition: Fuel-efficient vehicles often come with low-rolling-resistance tires that may be expensive to replace. Factor this into your total cost of ownership calculations.
SGI Requirements: All vehicles require SGI registration and inspection when purchased. Hybrid vehicles may have additional inspection requirements for high-voltage systems, so budget accordingly.
The Hidden Costs of Fuel Efficiency
While fuel-efficient vehicles save money at the pump, consider these additional factors:
Premium Fuel Requirements: Some turbocharged engines perform best with premium gasoline, which can offset some fuel savings.
Specialized Maintenance: Hybrid systems require technicians trained in high-voltage systems, which may limit your service options in Regina.
Replacement Parts: Hybrid-specific components like batteries, inverters, and electric motors cost more to replace than conventional parts.
Insurance Costs: Some fuel-efficient vehicles qualify for green vehicle discounts, while others may cost more to insure due to expensive technology.
Making the Right Choice for Saskatchewan Driving
Saskatchewan's unique driving conditions influence fuel efficiency significantly:
Highway Driving: Long stretches of highway driving favour conventional engines over hybrids, which excel in stop-and-go traffic.
Cold Weather Impact: All vehicles experience reduced fuel economy in winter, but hybrids may see larger decreases due to cabin heating demands and battery performance.
Remote Areas: Consider parts availability and service network coverage if you frequently travel to smaller Saskatchewan communities.
For comprehensive information about reliable used vehicles, check out our guide on most reliable used cars under $20,000, which covers additional models that balance efficiency with dependability.
Where to Find These Fuel-Efficient Gems
Regina's used car market offers good selection of fuel-efficient vehicles, though some models may require patience to find. Browse our complete inventory to see current availability, or use specific filters to narrow your search based on your preferences.
When you find a potential purchase, use our complete used car buying checklist to ensure you're making a smart investment.
Our Recommendation: The Clear Winner
After comparing fuel economy, reliability, ownership costs, and Saskatchewan-specific considerations, the Toyota Prius (2016-2020) emerges as our top recommendation for most Regina buyers seeking maximum fuel efficiency.
The Prius delivers unmatched fuel economy while maintaining Toyota's legendary reliability. Although it commands a premium over conventional vehicles, the fuel savings, low maintenance requirements, and strong resale value justify the investment for most drivers.
For buyers prioritizing conventional styling and driving dynamics, the Honda Civic (2016-2021) represents the best compromise between efficiency and engagement. Its proven reliability and lower purchase price make it an excellent alternative.
Budget-conscious buyers should consider the Nissan Versa, which delivers impressive fuel economy at an accessible price point, though long-term reliability may not match Honda or Toyota standards.
Regardless of which fuel-efficient used car you choose, proper maintenance, appropriate driving habits, and realistic expectations about cold-weather performance will help you maximize your fuel savings while enjoying reliable transportation across Saskatchewan's diverse landscape.